Faye's Pizza since 1957

 
Family Tuesday Night Special
Super Size Pizza*, Garlic Bread, & (1) Pitcher of Soda......     $16.99 +tax
*Up to (2) toppings, Dine-in Only
Wednesday Night Specials
All You Can Eat Spaghetti & Meatballs**....$6.99
**Including Salad, Baked Garlic Bread, and Drink. Dine-in Only


 

Build Your Own Faye's Pizza

Create Your Own Faye's Pizza

Our dough is made fresh daily; all our vegetables are hand chopped and our sausage is made fresh at Miesfeld's Meat Market in order to make the best pizza around. The times have changed but we haven't. Pizza done the original way just like 50 years ago. That's why we have the best pizza in Sheboygan!

Our Topping Selections:
    • Italian Sausage
    • Pepperoni
    • Canadian Bacon
    • Bacon
    • Beef
    • Chicken
    • Green Peppers
    • Anchovies
    • Mushrooms
  • Shrimp
  • Sweet Red Peppers
  • Jalapeno Peppers
  • Onions
  • Green Olives
  • Pineapple
  • Black Olives
  • Chopped Garlic
Additional cost below will be added to topping price for:
Shrimp, Extra Cheese, Extra Sausage
Small Medium Large Super
$.75 $1.00 $1.25 $1.50

Original Hand Tossed Crust
  Small - 10" Medium - 13" Large - 15" Super - 17"
Cheese $7.00 $8.75 $10.25 $11.75
One topping $8.00 $10.25 $11.75 $13.25
Two toppings $9.00 $1125 $13.25 $15.25
Three toppings $10.00 $12.25 $14.75 $17.25
Four toppings $11.00 $13.25 $16.25 $19.25
Specialty $11.50 $14.25 $17.25 $20.25

Deep Dish Crust Pizza
  Medium - 12" Large - 14"

 

Cheese $10.00 $11.50
One topping $11.50 $13.00
Two toppings $13.00 $15.00
Three toppings $14.50 $17.00
Four toppings $16.00 $19.00
Specialty $18.00 $21.00

Personal Pan Pizza
6" Thin Crust Mini Pizza - choose up to (3) toppings....................................... $5.25
not available for specialty pizzas (example: Taco or BLT)  

Gluten Free Crust
Gluten Free Crust - 10 "
Cheese (GF) $9.75
One topping (GF) $10.75
Two toppings (GF) $11.75
Three toppings (GF) $12.75
Four toppings GF) $13.75
Specialty (GF) $14.25

Faye's Frozen Pizza
Frozen Pizza's available for purchase. (Pickup only) $5.00

Gift Certificates
Available throughout the year for any occasion.
Fundraisers
We make frozen pizzas for various fundraising events.
Please call for more information. (920) 458-4171