Faye's Pizza since 1957

Family Tuesday Night Special
Super Size Pizza*, Garlic Bread, & (1) Pitcher of Soda......     $16.99 +tax
*Up to (2) toppings, Dine-in Only
Wednesday Night Specials
All You Can Eat Spaghetti & Meatballs**....$6.99
**Including Salad, Garlic Bread, and Drink.   Dine-in Only

Faye's House Deluxe Pizza
  • Faye's House Deluxe Pizza
    Faye's House Deluxe Pizza, only the best ingredients.
  • House Salad
    Our House Salad has only the freshest ingredients
  • New Faye's
    We've remodeled, more seating, seasonal patio and great ambiance.
  • Turtle Cheese Cake
    Enjoy one of our delicious, decadent deserts
  • Ala Carte
    Start your meal with a selection from our delicious Ala Carte menu.
  • Old Faye's
    Faye's restaurant, opened 1957.
  • Beverages
    If it's soda you want, we've got you covered. Serving wine and beer too.
  • Minestrone
    Delicious homemade soups, made fresh twice a day.
  • Dinners
    Our Italian Dinners range from Chicken Cacciatore to Baked Ziti.

Faye’s Pizza, A Unique Taste from a Unique Place

Faye’s Pizza is your Sheboygan, WI home for the finest handmade pizza anywhere.

Our traditional way of making pizza has not changed since we opened our doors.

The dough is made fresh daily, the vegetables are hand chopped, and Faye's special blend of seasonings are added to the sausage made special for us by Miesfeld’s Meat Market.

Our sauce is made from the same recipe used for generations.

Let’s not forget about the cheese - we use the freshest Wisconsin cheese to top all of our pizza.

Put this all together with our passion for great food and you get the best pizza anywhere.

You're not in the mood for our great pizza? Try one of our delicious subs, salads or fantastic dinners.

Faye's has been serving up great food since 1957, let us serve you.

Offering dine in, take-out and delivery.

Visit soon to enjoy our recently renovated indoor dining or enjoy our new patio.        (available seasonally and when weather permits)


Visit us on facebook
at Faye's Pizza


If your organization is searching for a fun and effective way to earn money. Faye's Pizza offers a great way to raise funds.
Learn More

Faye's Frozen Pizzas
Frozen Pizzas

Enjoy a great Faye's Pizza anytime.
Available throughout the Sheboygan area.


American Express Accepted Discover Card Accepted
Mastercard Accepted Visa Accepted