Fayes pizza company logo

Our Specialty is Thin Crust Pizza


• Italian Sausage • Pepperoni • Canadian Bacon • Bacon • Beef • Chicken

• Anchovies • Mushrooms • Green Peppers • Sweet Red Peppers • Onions

• Jalapeno Peppers • Black Olives • Green Olives • Pineapple • Chopped Garlic

Additional cost below will be added to the topping price for:

Shrimp, Extra Cheese, Extra Sausage


Cost per Topping:

Original Hand Tossed Crust

Specialty Pizzas

Taco Pizza

Our homemade taco meat is blended with our Faye’s pizza sauce baked with mozzarella cheese; then when it comes out of the oven topped with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, Tostitos chips, & black olives, served with salsa sauce and sour cream.

Extra sour cream served on the side $1.50

BLT Pizza

A delicious combination of Canadian bacon, fresh bacon pieces, and mozzarella cheese are baked together, and then when pizza comes out of the oven, it is topped with mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato.

Cajun Pizza

This spicy combination includes a special blend of Cajun seasoning, Faye’s Italian sausage, Onions, Sweet Red Peppers, and Jalapeño peppers. Yes Folks, these peppers are hot!

9in. Cauliflower Crust available

Gluten Free • Keto Friendly • Paleo Friendly

Bacon, Double Cheeseburger Deluxe

Beef, bacon, cheddar cheese, and mozzarella cheese are baked together, and then when the pizza comes out of the oven. Lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise are added to the top of this creation.

Faye’s House Deluxe Pizza

The original deluxe pizza from the 1950’s, Italian sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, black olives, green olives & mushrooms (anchovies optional).

Personal Pan Pizza

6” Thin Crust Mini Pizza – choose up to (3) toppings.  Not available for specialty pizzas (example:  Taco or BLT).

Meat Lovers Pizza

Sausage, beef, pepperoni, bacon, and Canadian bacon.

Buffalo or BBQ Chicken Pizza

Start with either Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce or Legend Larry’s™ Award-Winning Medium Sauce. Then top it with oven roasted chicken and any (2) of your favorite toppings served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.

Faye’s Veggie Pizza

The healthiest of all pizzas - onions, green peppers, tomatoes, green olives, black olives & mushrooms.


Original Crust Pizzas

Available for take-n-bake

Gluten Free Crust

Gluten free crust - 10"



One topping

Two toppings

Three toppings

Four toppings








Small               Medium          Large               Super

$.75                 $1.00               $1.25               $1.50

Small               Medium          Large               Super

10"                   13"                   15"                   17"

$7.25               $9.00               $10.50            $12.00

+$1.00           +$1.25               $1.50             +$2.00

Veggie Pizza Veggie Pizza

Contact us




Cost per topping

Deep Dish Crust

Medium          Large

12"                   14"

$9.00               $10.50

+$1.25             $1.50

*Prices are subject to change.

Hawaiian Pizza

Canadian bacon, bacon, pineapple, mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Oven-roasted chicken breast, smothered in a creamy garlic herb alfredo sauce. Comes with mozzarella cheese and asiago cheese.

If you choose, add up to 2 toppings.

Chicken Caeser Pizza

Roasted chicken breast, asiago, parmesean, and mozzarella cheese. Baked, then finished with tomatoes, crisp romaine and our special house caesar dressing drizzled over the top.

Frozen Crust


Our dough is made fresh daily; all our vegetables are hand chopped and our

meat is made fresh from Miesfeld’s Meat Market in order to make the best

pizza around, the times have changed but we haven’t. Pizza done the original

way just like 62 years ago. That’s why we are the best pizza in Sheboygan!